Why Rhetoric? A recent experience...


Issue #5

Why Rhetoric?

Some of you may think you don't need persuasive abilities so long as you have the truth on your side. I thought that for quite some time too... until I knew better.

Aristotle has written thoroughly on the importance of rhetoric, but this time I want to draw from my own recent experience.

If you think rhetoric is not important, try explaining someone a very basic and well-known (not to them) concept, something like the halo effect. The pushback you'll receive - "Oh no, I would never judge people by how they look", yeah sure, Monica - will demonstrate just how important rhetoric is in day to day life.

People act in highly irrational ways.

They are typically much less open-minded than they perceive themselves to be, and would oppose somethings purely for the sake of opposing, without any seemingly rational cause.

(You're no exception to this, btw, so be on the lookout for this in yourself too. I shall do the same.)

Recently I was telling someone (whom I consider decently, if not extremely bright) that slides help the audience be anchored to a lecture, and that the lack of them may cause the audience to get lost and being unable to find their way back.

I thought this was obvious.

(I still think it is... especially to people who listen to 4 lectures a day.)

But apparently not. The kind of pushback I got... mind-boggling.

"No, I don't think so. I never find it difficult."

What?

And that just reinforced this belief in me... sometimes, it doesn't matter how right you are, or how correct some ideas may be... some people cannot be convinced.

Their minds function like a complex lock, which can't be opened just with the truth, but only with the right key.

Rhetoric is that key.

See ya later,

Ayush

113 Cherry St #92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2205
Unsubscribe · Preferences

The Rhetorician

An attempt to revive the lost art of rhetoric. Discussing concepts, ideas, and techniques pertaining to elegant and persuasive communication.

Read more from The Rhetorician

The Rhetorician Issue #12 GIFT: Metaphor Repository Dear Reader, Metaphors are among the most effective tools in The Rhetorician's arsenal. A well placed metaphor is like a nuke that ends the argument cleanly and instantly, destroying any scope of counter-arguments. Case in point - "A house divided against itself cannot stand" by Abraham Lincoln. A century and a half later, this metaphor is still as popular as ever. Can there be a more effective argument for a nation to be united? In your...

The Rhetorician Issue #11 They’re Not Idiots for Not Agreeing With You Same World, Different Models. Src - ChatGPT. TLDR - Just because someone sounds irrational to you doesn’t mean they’re stupid or evil. It just means their mental model of the world is different from yours. We all build simplified versions of reality based on what we’ve seen, heard, and lived—and then we act rationally inside those models. So persuasion isn’t about hitting people with better logic—it’s about entering their...

The Rhetorician Issue #10 Freedom of Choice (Really?) Readers, That job you took?That feature you used?That policy you agreed with? Chances are, you didn’t choose it. You were nudged—cleverly, quietly—into consenting. Not by force, not by argument. But by design. This is manufactured consent, and it runs everything from politics to product. The most dangerous thing about it? You don’t notice it. And worse—when done well, you think it was your idea. Let’s get sharper. Manufactured consent is...